Setting the momentum for Wildlife Conservation

Co-existence or encroachment? As rapid urbanization advances, Sweri, one of the few remaining
staging areas of Lesser and Greater Flamingoes in Mumbai faces a serious threat.
The International Year of Biodiversity (IYB) has nearly come to an end. Like every year, many ambitious, successful projects were implemented this year – from community based conservation of backyards and watersheds, to national projects pertaining conservation of forest corridors, to international programs such as the Tiger Summit and the expeditions to discover new species of plants and animals. Other recent findings such as the discovery of microbial communities deep beneath the sea floor and bacteria that can substitute phosphorous with arsenic, made sure the IYB had a successful ending. But the end of this fruitful year is in fact a kick-start to the conservation efforts whose results will be seen in years down yonder.

Although many conservation projects were undertaken this year, it didn’t really turn out quite well. On 26th January 2010, Boa Sr, the only survivor of Bo tribe from the Great Andamanese Islands passed away. A tribe is now extinct – a culture lost forever. The Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill led to vast ecological and economic loss, creating a great environmental uproar. The Haiti earthquake and Chile earthquake shook everyone, as did the flooding in Pakistan. 2010 was also recorded as the hottest year in decades, perhaps the reason for Russian and Israeli wildfires. On the other side, the world’s first international summit, held in November for any wild animal – the Tiger Summit 2010, was a bit of a relief in tiger conservation efforts. The WWF said “this summit could be a historic turning point for tigers”. If the largest conservation organization has expressed its contentment in such a summit, I am more than just optimistic for the survival of this mighty beast. Indeed the summit is just a beginning; how much the project can deliver will only be seen in the coming years. Interestingly, as this year kick-started the drive for wildlife conservation and hopefully the associated sustainable development, scientists from Japan, in May 2010, suggested a Biodiversity Decade for the years 2011 to 2019 – called the International Biodiversity Decade, to the UN. I am greatly pleased by this proposal, and hope that the world leaders and the UN adopt this idea.
The yet-untouched forests of Sanjay Gandhi National Park, Mumbai
The world has been through a grim economic recession only comparable to the Great Depression, and we are still recovering. With the idea for an International Biodiversity Decade, I envision a different path towards economic – and yet sustainable – development. The CBD implemented many projects under IYB, with the main priority of public awareness about the fast vanishing biodiversity. The projects gave everyone an opportunity to learn, earn and share knowledge. If a year can deliver education and employment via various sectors, imagine how many more opportunities will be created in a decade dedicated to biodiversity.

There exists a strong opinion towards employment opportunities in the fields related to the environment. The misconception that biodiversity only revolves around wildlife and environment, is not exactly true; it also encompasses social and economical aspects, and these three factors, called the Triple Bottom Line, are very crucial for any advanced civilization. Now if a decade is dedicated to protecting biodiversity, many more projects will be proposed in the coming years, many funds will become available, as well as many more people will work for the same. Socially and economically, everyone directly or indirectly linked with the environment will benefit – but not at the cost of the environment. It may sound too farfetched, but a sustainable world via eco-friendly living, harvesting nonconventional energy, water conservation and so on, can, in the long run, be healthy for the environment and profitable to every nation. This, of course, is the scenario that considers high public awareness and sensitivity to environmental concerns.
Urbanization competing with aforestation
We all know that the calamities that befell this year were all socially and environmentally devastating. They were also, more importantly, a big siren – an alarm call that we as humans are also susceptible to natural calamities. That, we have medicines or can easily avert a disaster is a very ignorant point of view. And even though we are highly intelligent and resilient, we are still at the mercy of nature. Whether climate change is brought upon by man or not, just as we claim the right over the natural resources, it is also our responsibility to protect these resources. It may take many more disasters for man to realize this, but we must act now, for it may become too late to protect ourselves from natural disasters in the future, perhaps brought upon my man himself.
Future of every wetland ecosystem? Uran, a vast network of wetlands lies covered in landfill, thanks to the SEZ - many birds
lost prime breeding and hunting habitats, and many fishermen lost their primary means of earning.
Today, there are environment-related problems in every community, and through direct public engagement they can be solved. I cannot think of a better person as an example than Majora Carter, an activist who fought for environmental justice for her community. Unfortunately, there have been incidences where corporate powers have exploited environment’s vulnerability – such was the case of Uran, a rich, ecologically significant wetland habitat now ravaged by bulldozers and trucks to make way for industries. We do not realize the cost we may pay in the future, for many see opportunity in economy alone, and many still argue that this is in best interest of the locals. If only environment was given the needed attention, Uran would be a thriving eco-tourism hotspot – contributing significantly to the economy of the region. The ongoing scuffle over encroachment in few remaining wildlife habitats of Mumbai and other cities is also a major concern, which can be tackled at a public as well as governmental level, through steps such as public awareness, nature appreciation, and community participation in environmental issues. We can easily take up the responsibility to protect our surroundings with only a little change in our lifestyle. And when is a better time to start than on the eve of a new year and a new decade?
--
Also read: International Biodiversity Year

Diptera of Mumbai

Update (November 27, 2017): A detailed paper (with more pictures) has now been published. See it here.

“With buzzing wings she hung aloft,
Then near and nearer drew,
Thinking only of her brilliant eyes,
And green and purple hue-”
- Mary Howitt 1821
A Robberfly scanning the grassland of SGNP
Introduction

There are over 1000 species of plants, 251 birds, 40 species of mammals, and it is estimated that there are approximately 5000 species of insects in Sanjay Gandhi National Park, and I estimate there to be more species of insects in Mumbai and the surrounding areas. Among insects, the diversity of butterflies is very well documented in Mumbai, and is the only insect in Class Insecta that is studied so well. Then there are arachnids that are well documented, yet not comprehensively put together into one pictured guide. In all these innumerable Orders we explore, what we don’t see is other creatures living not only in forests but in the city itself. Some insects are so common that we tend to overlook them. One such not-so-beautiful creature to look for is a fly. It is not difficult to see a fly, many nature enthusiasts do, and many take pictures too. However, there is not enough information on how many flies call Mumbai their home, except for some highly specific research papers which are not easily (or freely) accessible for amateur naturalists. The knowledge of biodiversity gained through research should be available freely – especially on the internet – since I think this is the prime reason why there is such a big lacuna in the biodiversity study of Mumbai, or any other city in India. But let’s keep it aside to discuss some other time and focus on Diptera today.

Diptera is one of the 29 orders of Insecta. There are 188 families in Diptera, and the number of species is estimated to be 1 million, of which only 150,000 different kinds of flies are known to us. With such an abundant diversity, it is surprising to see no information on Diptera of Mumbai. This is partly because Diptera is not as beautiful a family as Lepidoptera. It doesn’t even sound cool. All dipterans are small compared to Lepidoptera or Coleoptera. Simply put, they are not worth noticing, and are plain ugly. I do not blame anyone for not seeing a fly but it’s not just about the looks! The major reason behind finding it unattractive is because we have learnt since childhood – flies spread diseases. If you see a fly, swat it. If you see a fly sit on your food, don’t eat it. Although this is not true for all flies, our education doesn’t say which fly is dirty – a housefly or any other fly. It only teaches us to keep away from flies. So, with all due respect to other beautiful insects out there, I bring the family of flies up from their “dirty” reputation, alongside all the other beautiful creatures of Mumbai.

I started writing this article after finishing Common Spider Families of Mumbai, but I never got around it. It has been a year since that article, and I received a good response from many naturalists in and around Mumbai. This is an article on one of the insects of Mumbai’s forests that I happened to study – and with this article, I will post some more Biodiversity of Mumbai articles in a few more years to come.

Flies. I like flies as much as they like to annoy us, and as much as we like to whack them and some love to fly away from us as much as we like to run after them for a photograph. And with flies such as houseflies to annoy us, there are other beautiful flies around, some are blood-thirsty, some flower-loving, some predatory, some parasitic, some dancers and some pests. This is enough to sum the vast diversity of Diptera in Mumbai, but if we are to study them closely – they are bizarre, alien, and unlike butterflies, lack common names (making them even more painful to identify), as is the case with most moths seen in India.

Methodology

The area covered was in and around Mumbai, including the suburbs. The observations were made at Sanjay Gandhi National Park (including Yeoor Hills, Nagla Block and IIT-Mumbai areas), Tungareshwar Wildlife Sanctuary, Karnala Bird Sanctuary, Matheran ESA, Thane, Karjat, Vasai Fort, Mahuli Fort, Jijamata Udyan and Mahim Nature Park. All the flies were seen and documented on nature walks; hence the sampling was random, and done over a period of three years (2007 to 2009). Most flies documented were also photographed; however there are non-photographic records of few families.

Identifications were made solely based on photographs, therefore very few flies are completely identified up to genus, but the checklist of the families was made with help from experts via internet. This is not a comprehensive checklist, but an attempt at recording all the Diptera sightings occurring over a period of three years. This also does not give the confirmed number of families, as I must have missed several of them; some of the families are in fact beyond identification unless they are observed under a microscope. I relied mostly on journal articles and research papers from India, but no papers were available pertaining to the state of Maharashtra.

Account

After I researched on the little known Bugs of Mumbai, I realized how few Dipterans are known to me. This is one of the most challenging orders to study, therefore it is not surprising to see scientist and taxonomists reordering and renaming them all the time. The New Diptera Site has a good deal of information on Classification of Diptera. Web-sources like this inspired me to reopen the old pictures and get them identified as fairly as possible. I do not like to keep anything unidentified, but sometimes some images get overlooked – as was a case with the Dipterans.

Describing a fly is very easy. It stands for “two-winged” creature, where a pair of forewings is used for flight, and the hind-wings are reduced, called “halteres”, which assist in flight. We all know how hard it is to swat a fly. They are one of the strongest and quickest fliers living, and behind their swiftness is a complex mechanism of balance, strong thoracic muscles and nervous coordination.

The flies mentioned here is my personal checklist of Diptera families. In all, I came across 22 confirmed families existing in Mumbai, excluding the confusing families of Midges and Gnats, and some other unconfirmed families (approximately 30 families). None of these fly families are rare, so I expect to find some more, rare and inquisitive families exclusive to Western Ghats. In fact, all the families listed here are the top 20 largest families of Diptera (Brown, 2005). Several flies are threatened by loss or degradation of habitats. The IUCN Red List includes seven species, of which three are extinct; two are listed endangered, one critically endangered and one as vulnerable. The species-at-risk flies are from United States and Australia. I am assuming there is no literature available on the internet on Indian Dipteral species-at-risk.

Understanding flies is very important to us, not merely because we must map the biodiversity – that’s not why everyone will look at flies, but because flies are the most important arthropod vectors of disease in humans and animals. They are responsible for most insect-borne diseases and deaths than any. With flies such as mosquitoes – the dreaded host for malaria and other diseases, to parasitic flies such as Blowflies and Horseflies, to pests such as Fruit flies, to flower-loving Hoverflies, supreme predatory Robber flies and thieves like the Kleptoparasitic flies – who would think that flies are merely just… flies? This behavioral diversity is not seen in Odonata or it’s not so extreme in Lepidoptera and Coleoptera.

Observations

The families seen in Mumbai are described herein, starting from the most common, to the uncommon and lastly the uncertain, confusing fly families, such as Midges, Gnats and others.

CULICIDAE

Better known as Mosquitoes, Culicidae literally means a little fly. There are about 20 genus of Culicidae in India, and several hundred species. They are the most dreaded, hated and commonest flies seen. As we are aware, only the females need to feed on a protein-rich diet of blood, for nourishing the eggs. The males feed off on plant sap, and seldom visit houses. The mosquitoes manage to find their victim by acute sense of odour, thanks to the olfactory nerves in the antennae.
A freshly emerged Tiger Mosquito - Aedes sp.
Mosquitoes are omnipresent in Mumbai, but identifying them up to species level is impossible without a microscope. Species of Aedes, Culex and Anopheles are the common ones. Identifying the mosquitoes is usually based on the difference in mouth-parts; it also helps differentiate male from a female.

We know where mosquitoes breed since this is the insect which has gained highest public awareness, for obvious reasons. Best way to get rid of mosquitoes is not only to remove stagnant water, but also to breed fishes. Other alternatives are having Odonates – the naiads as well as adults – in the backyard or other predatory flies such as Robber flies. These are one of the most efficient natural mosquito population controllers.

MUSCIDAE

The family of House flies. I did not come across a species checklist for India, but one paper on Northeast India states 108 species in Muscidae. I cannot speculate the number for Mumbai, but the diversity in Muscidae is interesting enough to be mapped. It will help understand the harmful flies as well as the useful flies for Mumbai region.
A Housefly in the genus Musca
Most common fly is Musca domestica – the Housefly we see everywhere. These are considered pest flies and are known to spread about 16 diseases. It is the fly because of which we fail to understand other useful flies that act as pollinators. There are several Muscid flies seen in Mumbai, easily distinguished from Musca domestica, by colour patterns, but confirmed identification will require microscopic observations.

SYRPHIDAE

If you ever associated flies with flowers, Syrphidae is a family you will mostly cherish. They come in various shapes and sizes, from tiny Hover-flies to large Syrphid flies (not all Syrphid flies are Hoverflies, because they do not hover). This family of flies is known to mimic bees and wasps. Besides sitting on flowers, the Hover-flies are commonly seen hovering midair, hence the common name. This is another common family of flies that are seen throughout the seasons, although less in numbers during winter.

Hoverfly
Syrphid fly
A mating pair of Hoverflies
They provide an ecological service of pollination, hence are ecologically useful. The larvae either feed on decaying material, or aphids, thus playing a role of biological pest controllers. This beneficial fly is seen throughout the city and wooded areas.

CALLIPHORIDAE

Commonly called Blue-bottle flies or Blow flies, these shiny flies are also amongst the most common seen around. Whether it’s a rotting animal, decaying plant matter or feces, this fly will be abundant at such places to lay eggs. They are also efficient pollinators, and often visit various flowers, especially those that give out a pungent odour. These flies are also important in their larval stage, since the maggots help breakdown of the decomposing animals. The maggots are used in Maggot Therapy, since the maggots exclusively feed on dead tissue. The most common genera of this fly are Lucilia sp. (Blue-bottle fly), and Chrysomya sp. (Blowfly).
Blowfly - Probable genus Chrysomya
Bengalia sp.
Possibly Stomorhynca sp.
The rather interesting fly that belongs to this family is Bengalia sp., that are kleptoparasitic since the adults snatch food and pupa carried by ants, or feed on winged termites (Source). They usually sit a little away from the marching ants – keeping an eye on them – and snatch their catch. I have only observed one specimen at Sanjay Gandhi National Park. Who would have thought there are such smart thief flies out there? This family of flies, although a menace because of their abundance is important in order to carry out various ecosystem services, such as decomposition.

SARCOPHAGIDAE

Sarcophagid flies are commonly called Flesh flies, mainly because most species lay eggs in dead animals. For this reason, forensic entomologists can predict the time of the death of a person, if the body is affected by Flesh flies, since different species prefer different body organs in different states of decomposition (Source). Other species are known to lay eggs in open wounds, but I don’t think that is a problem in Mumbai. And some species are predatory on insect larvae and mollusks. I came across an interesting paper, where the researchers studied Sarcophaga misera, a species known to prey on a freshwater snail Indoplanorbis exustus, a vector of schistosomiasis. The research shows that larvae of the fly killed the snail within 15 to 60 mins. It also states that chemicals are usually used to control these snails, but if there are natural pest controllers such as these flies out there, we don’t need to pollute the environment so much! The paper can be accessed here.
Flesh fly - Parasarcophaga sp.
Although there are many Flesh flies around in Mumbai, it is not easy to identify the species, unless the genitalia are observed. Hence I can’t be sure of different species seen in Mumbai, but now we at least know how important they are to the ecosystem.

ASILIDAE

The flies belonging to Asilidae are commonly called Robber flies. They are aerodynamic predatory flies, very common throughout forested areas. The common name Robber flies is probably because they are known to snatch prey off other flies, but most often, they capture their prey themselves. There are large to small Robber flies, easily identifiable by their long abdomen, laterally flattened body and “mustache” like bristles on the head. Their eyes are well developed, and legs designed to hold onto prey. Robber flies, while hunting, prefer to perch on a vantage point, from where they are able to watch clearly for approaching prey or predator. While basking, they will either sit on the leaf or on an exposed branch. Seeing these flies, which are quite common, is also an indication that the insect diversity of that area is healthy. The adults put up an interesting courtship display as males hover over the female, while attempting to copulate. There are many more complex subtle courtship displays in Asilidae. The adults lay eggs on the ground or on plants. The larvae feed on organic matter in the ground. This shows that larvae help in accelerating decomposition of dung as well as wood, and the adults help keep populations of other insects such as mosquitoes in check. These beautiful flies are everything except robbers!
A Bee-like Robber fly
A Robber fly feeding on an Ant
Robber fly feeding on a Leaf hopper
There are several species seen in Mumbai [in subfamily Laphriinae (first picture), Asilinae (second picture) and Leptogastrinae (third picture)], but I haven’t been able to identify them merely through photographs. Generally, only a few genuses of Robber flies have a Common name, such as Bee-like Robber flies that are seen in Mumbai, but usually they are referred to as only Robber flies. Only through specimen collection and microscopic observations can someone confirm the species. As predicted, there is no online literature available on Asilidae of Mumbai.

DOLICHOPODIDAE

Dolichopodidae is the family of Long-legged Flies. These tiny, metallic flies are the jewels of the fly world. Most species flaunt a shiny green exoskeleton, but there are other forms that come in hues of yellow to blue. They are common in urban as well as wooded areas – although I have observed their populations declining in urban areas.
Long-legged fly

These tiny flies are seen dancing from leaf to leaf, or from fruit to fruit. These tiny flies are predatory, feeding on smaller bugs. It is always a pleasure to chase these flies for photography, but what’s interesting to photograph is their courtship dance. The males rapidly move the wings up and down without actually flying. Some species exhibit ornamented wing tips, with either a white tip or black-and-white tips in some. I recommend reading the article by Zimmer et al (2003) for more information on how courtship displays evolved in relation to the other closely related-fly families.

As is true for most fly families, identifying Long-legged flies based on a photograph is almost impossible. In fact, all the flies look same to me, except of course a few obvious morphological features such as colour, length and size of legs, as well as differences in behaviour and habitats. They are however identified based on the genitalia of males. The genus Dolichopus is the most commonly occurring, with about 600 species, although I wouldn’t predict all Long-legged Flies of Mumbai to be the same.

BOMBYLIIDAE

Flies belonging to this family are commonly called Bee flies, because of their superficial resemblance to bees. This fly-in-disguise thus gets protection from this sort of mimicry, as the predators who have experienced the sting of a bee will almost certainly avoid it. Such kind of mimicry, called Batesian mimicry, is common in many insects – and is well-known in butterflies. Although Bee-flies do resemble bees, many species are not as good at mimicking bees as other families of flies such as Syrphidae are. The adults are small; often show patterns on wings, with fluffy bodies. They are undoubtedly the soft-toys of the fly world! The adults exclusively feed on nectar, thereby voluntarily helping in pollination. The larvae are predatory or parasitic of other insects. According to Wikipedia, it is the poorest known families of insects relative to its species diversity.
One of the common Beeflies of Mumbai
Mumbai boasts a good population of Bee flies (click here to see another type of Bee fly, photographed by Dinesh Valke at Yeoor Hills), most of them yet unknown to the common people. All we know is that they are Bee flies, but if we are to study them closely, we need to know which Bee fly is which. We might perhaps discover the key used in identification of these flies, or discover a new species!

DROSOPHILIDAE

Drosophila, or Fruit fly, is well known in kitchens as a nuisance and in labs for their (voluntary?) contribution to genetics. I had no picture of a Drosophila (or a similar species from this family), since they were just too common and too tiny to photograph.
A dead Drosophila
There are many flies in Diptera that are commonly referred to as Fruit flies, but the flies belonging to Drosophilidae are the true fruit flies. Although they are just about everywhere, identifying them to species level requires expertise. Many species of these flies are considered serious pests on fruits; therefore their identity in Mumbai is important in order to curb the pest populations using biological pest control techniques.

PHORIDAE

Flies in this family are called Scuttle flies for a good reason. They look similar to Fruit flies mentioned above, and are equally common in houses. The easiest way to distinguish a Scuttle fly is, if you go after it, instead of flying, just how a Fruit fly would, they will run very quickly and then take to wings. This could be attributed to their heavily built mid- and hind-legs.
Scuttle fly, probably Megaselia scalaris
The most widespread species is Megaselia scalaris, common in warm climates and temperate areas. These flies are considered pests - especially in the kitchen, where adults lay eggs in a variety of organic materials - from meat to decaying plants. The larvae are known to infect incompletely healed wounds, causing myiasis. They are known to infest cockroaches, crickets and other arthropods as well as reptiles (source). Best way to keep them out of homes is to keep organic foods and garbage well contained.

PSYCHODIDAE

Commonly called Drain flies, because they are more common near damp places – such as drains, or Moth flies, because of their resemblance to moths, these flies are, although small, hard to miss. They are very common, and don’t cause any nuisance. Their presence is as good as their absence. This is one reason why I never thought about photographing one, but I promise to get one – for no special reason – soon.
A Moth fly showing fuzzy scales and moth-like antennae
Unfortunately, that is not all. Some genus of these flies (especially Sandfly) spread Leishmaniasis, and one of its types – Kala Azar. It is better to be prepared by knowing which fly spreads which disease, as there have been outbreaks of Kala Azar in Mumbai and only through public awareness can we prevent the fly from biting.

TIPULIDAE

Tipulidae is the family of Crane flies, which are also called daddy long-legs, although it is used for any insect or spider with extremely long, thin legs. The Crane flies probably get their names because of the same reason – their long, thin legs. Someone must have pictured these flies to resemble cranes. They are harmless flies, although people consider them to be giant mosquitoes that give a painful bite. But Crane flies do not bite – the adults feed on nectar (pollination!) and their larvae feed on mosquito larvae (biological pest control!). Yet, with all the misconception regarding their scary appearance and the belief that they bite, these flies, unsurprisingly, do not get the fame they deserve.
A male Crane fly, Ctenophora sp.
Crane flies are seen in good numbers in and around Mumbai, but I wouldn’t call them abundant. Best season to see a Crane fly is during monsoon, as many adults emerge from the aquatic larvae. One genus of flies is Ctenophora sp., which is most common in Mumbai. The males show an upturned scorpion-like abdomen with a stinger-like projection at the end. Luckily, this is just the genitalia of the male, and is not used to sting. Having these around – more commonly near wetlands, where their larva grow – is a good sign that your plants are being pollinated, and the mosquito larvae are under check.

These 11 families are most common, now we will look at the rather uncommon families. Uncommon because they are not found in abundance compared to the families above, and some are also difficult to identify.

MICROPEZIDAE

This family is dominated by ant- and wasp-mimicking flies commonly called as Stilt-legged Flies. They are quite larger than a House fly, with a very distinctive behaviour. The Stilt-legged flies get their name from, but of course, the stilt-like legs. These flies, when at rest, move their body forward and backwards, with the constant wavy movement of the short forelegs, wearing white socks. This constant waving is probably a way to mimic wasp antennae movement – since many wasps wave their antennae as they search for prey. These flies are also distinct because one species of Stilt-legged fly is wingless. Yes, a wingless fly (irony?), found in the Australian region. This family also contains a species-at-risk in Kerguelen Islands (in the Indian Ocean). The larvae of these flies are known to feed on ginger, or live under bark of dead trees. Some adults are predatory on small insects, or are attracted to excrement and decaying fruits – as observed in Mumbai.
A mating pair of Stilt-legged flies, possibly Rainieria sp.,
also notice short forelegs
Mumbai probably houses a single species, or only one species is predominantly seen around. The species is still unidentified (however, the genus could be Rainieria sp.). These flies are common during monsoon months, when they prefer to rest on leaf surface and wave their legs. The closest related family is Neriidae, about which I will talk later.

STRATIOMYIDAE

Soldier flies are small, fast flying flies. They are usually seen sitting on leaf surfaces, and if disturbed, fly rapidly to-and-fro, and settle on a nearby leaf. These flies come in a variety of colours, with metallic green being most dominant. They are long and slender – somewhat resembling a wasp, and sit with their wings folded one on the other over the abdomen. The larvae are aquatic or terrestrial, feeding on dead and decaying matter while some are predatory.
Soldier fly, Sargus sp.
Probably Odontomyia sp.
These not-so-common flies are easy to distinguish because of their typical morphology as discussed above. I have recorded only two types (probably two different species) of Soldier flies in Mumbai, of which the most common is Sargus sp., and only one different Soldier fly pictured above was seen at IIT-Mumbai.

CHIRONOMIDAE

Commonly known as Non-biting Midges, the Chironomids are by far most commonly occurring flies, perhaps very close to Mosquitoes. We all know what these flies are, and we all wonder if these are mosquitoes. Even Zoology students have dissected their larvae – called Chironomous larvae, or in lay-mans term – Bloodworms. Even aquarium hobbyists feed these Bloodworms to their fish. These Chironomous larvae are called Bloodworms because of their colour – they do not contain red blood. The larvae belong to several species of Non-biting Midges, many resembling mosquitoes (with absence of long mouthparts, but they don’t bite.
Non-biting Midge
The ones we commonly recognize are green mosquitoes. I have not identified which species is most abundant in Mumbai, but it is easy to recognize these green midges. They are completely harmless, but might be a nuisance since they invade where there is a source of light. The adults are important pollinators, while the larvae help in breakdown of dissolved organics in water.

TABANIDAE

It is the dreaded family of deadly flies, commonly called Horseflies and Deerflies. These flies have saw-like mandibles that they pierce and saw (quite literally) to drain blood; they then happily lap up the dripping blood. The Horseflies are usually larger than Deerflies, with a very painful bite, with some species known to even pull tiny chunks of skin! I have been chased by several Horse flies at Dandeli-Anshi Tiger Reserve. We were travelling through an open jeep to studying population dynamics of ungulates. And we were being stalked by big, sturdy flying machines that could match the speed of 40 to 50 kmph for over an hour! In fact, these Horseflies (Tabanus sp.) also rested on the jeep occasionally. I was in the passenger seat, trying to get rid of these pirates – but to no avail. I haven’t been bitten by a Horsefly yet, but had an experience with Deerflies.
A male Horsefly in the genus Tabanus
Deerflies are small, rather ornately coloured with cryptic designs on their wings and almost hypnotizing eyes. They are swift, and given the small size, easily stalk and get a bite out of you. Their bite isn’t very painful, but it’s more than that of a Mosquito, but less than that of an Arboreal Ant sting. The pain and itching subsides quickly. It is the Horseflies that are very common, especially during monsoon and post-monsoon months near SGNP (mostly at Yeoor Hills, Nagla Block and Matheran). These little buggers and their cousins will feed on mammals and birds in the wild, but will happily drink off humans too. It is only the females that need blood, just like mosquitoes, while males prefer to feed on plant sap. I emailed Prof. S N Hegde from the University of Mysore, who helped me narrow down the possible genus of the two species I recorded in Mumbai. The Horsefly (pictured) is Philoliche sp., and the Deerfly (pictured) is probably a Haematopota sp. – both photographed at Yeoor and Nagla Block. Tabanus sp. I mentioned earlier has not been seen, but it is more-so common along Western Ghats as you go south from Mumbai.
Horsefly, Philoliche sp.
An Orb-weaver feeding on Philoliche sp. Horsefly
A Deerfly in the genus Haematopota
The Philoliche sp. is common only in some patches of forest either with a thick canopy or a clearing. I have observed them feeding on cattle at Yeoor as well. Haematopota sp. is rather spread out in rural as well as wooded areas. While the adults are ferocious, their larvae are voracious predators of snails and earthworms – amongst other invertebrates.

MILICHIIDAE

If there are flies that steal, the Milichiidae flies should rightly be called thief flies, but there is another better name that explains this family. The flies of this family are commonly called Freeloader flies, because they are “someone who exploits chances to get free stuff wherever possible”. This kind of behaviour is more correctly called Kleptoparasitism (parasitism by theft). This is a highly specialized family (like all other Diptera families) but their skill lies in thieving. As a pickpocket has developed the pick pocketing skill, several flies here have learnt how to coax ants to regurgitate, and feed on it. Other flies prefer hanging around predators (invertebrates and lizards, mostly) and feed on their hard earned food. While the adults secretly feed off other’s prey, the larvae feed on dead and decaying plant matter.
Freeloader flies feeding on a bee caught by a Crab spider
The Freeloader flies (or Kleptoparasitic flies) of Mumbai have been seen commonly around spiders – feeding off their captured prey. These flies, thus, do not harm the spider directly, but affect the amount of nutrients the spider gets. Can you imagine eating tandoori while scores of flies lap up the juices? This is exactly what the spiders of Mumbai go through, and sadly they can’t swat the flies either. On the other hand, these flies do help keep the populations of spider in check – as we don’t want too many healthy spiders feeding on too many bees – this will inevitably reduce pollination as bees will just die, if not for these spider thieves! Even though kleptoparasitic flies keep spider diet in check, it must take a lot of flies to reduce a spider’s ability to kill bees visiting flowers.
Probably Freeloader flies on Lemon Pansy butterfly
The other interesting behaviour of flies that I mentioned previously here, is hitchhiking on butterflies. These flies probably are parasitic as well, or are just too lazy to fly to another potential predator that they can steal from. In fact, I think these flies know that the butterfly is going to fall prey to a spider someday – and just settle on its wings – which, if caught by a spider or a praying mantis, can easily feed on it. Crazy world of flies, isn’t it? The reason for this speculation is because I have not come across any article that explains this kind of behaviour. They are too tiny to even photograph, adding to their mystery.

TEPHRITIDAE

While Tephritidae might not be experts in capturing prey or robbing others, they are well equipped to damage fruits. Flies of this family, hence, are also called Fruit flies. They are also called Peacock flies because of their elaborate colours and wing markings. Most of these flies are larger than Drosophilidae, and show presence of ovipositors at the end of the abdomen, with which they penetrate fruits to lay eggs. This family is therefore agriculturally important because of their damage to crops (fruits), but there are also several species that prefer weeds, thus helping in destroying them.
Melon fly, Bacterocera sp. seen at Yeoor Hills
There are several species of Peacock flies in Mumbai, but the most significant one probably is Bactrocera sp. These flies seem to mimic Paper Wasps, and just like the wasps, are also seen in little groups. It could be a strategy used to deter predators. While I am not sure which other species are seen in Mumbai, I have observed Bactrocera sp. only at Yeoor Hills till now. This might sound like a warning bell for local fruit growers, as these flies are notorious pests. There are several common names for Bactrocera sp., but the main concern in Mumbai could be the one called Melon Fly. Other Peacock flies can be viewed on BugGuide.

DIOPSIDAE

Diopsidae is also one of my favorite families of flies. These outwardly flies are indeed alien-like compared to other flies. They are commonly called Stalk-eyed flies for an obvious reason. The males possess long stalked eyes, while females have shorter stalks, with females preferring males with long stalked eyes. During mating season, the males pump air via mouth into the stalks, thereby elongating it.
A male Stalk-eyed Fly photographed at Kanheri Hills, SGNP
While I have no idea which species resides in Mumbai, these flies are only seen in small groups at certain locations. I have come across two, one at a small stream at SGNP and one at Tungareshwar, although I am sure they are more common than where I have seen. What’s interesting though is that they only prefer certain forested areas and are always near a stream (because that’s where they lay eggs and hatch). These flies could probably be the indicators of a healthy habitat, but more observations need to be made to ascertain this conclusion.

HIPPOBOSCIDAE

The flies are commonly called Louse flies or Keds. They are as common as there are pigeons in Mumbai. This is because the Pigeon Louse flies fall in this family. They are dorsoventrally flattened, always hiding beneath the feathers. I as a kid used to allow pigeons to nest in the balcony, and that's when I discovered these flies. Luckily, they do not prefer human blood, or at least not my blood. They are weak fliers; in fact some species have given up flying forever.

CELYPHIDAE

This family is very unique (yes, all are as a matter of fact), and is not hard to mistake it for a beetle to an untrained eye, and for this reason, the flies in this family are called Beetle-backed flies, or just Beetle flies. While there have been records of this family from Thane city, I am yet to stumble upon these tiny flies. The scutellum in these flies is enlarged, much like beetles and jewel-bugs, which almost covers the wings - hence it looks like a beetle, although easiest way to distinguish it from any beetle is the distinct fly-like head, fly-like stubby antennae and mouth parts.

We had a look at the families that are confirmed to be present in Mumbai, now let’s have a look at the families that may be present in Mumbai.

EMPIDIDAE

Flies of this family are commonly referred to as Dagger flies (because of dagger-shaped mouth parts) and also as Dance flies (although the original Dance flies belong to Hybotidae). These are mainly predatory flies, but I photographed them sipping nectar (which, some species certainly do). They are not commonly observed because they are very small, and let’s face it – many of us amateur naturalists chase big things like butterflies and scorpions. Empididae is one of the three families in the super family Empidoidea, which also includes Dolichopodidae (we already had a look at these).
Dagger flies engaged in territorial display or courtship
 on Neanotis lancifolia
Only these two flies have been seen until now, and although they could be very common than I think, this is probably the only photographic record from Mumbai on the internet. There are many species of Empididae in India, with many, of course, in the Western Ghats as well – hence it is not surprising to find them in Mumbai. The flies photographed were nectaring on Neanotis lancifolia, a small perennial herb. They were seen dancing, by raising their forelegs in air and waving at each other. Their size was less than a centimeter. While my identification could be wrong, I will appreciate another opinion on what this fly could be – till then, it remains an enigmatic, rare record for Empididae of Mumbai!

PTYCHOPTERIDAE

The flies of this family are commonly called Phantom Craneflies (not to be confused with Tipulidae). They come in various sizes, but the ones I am interested in from Mumbai are mostly small and thin, with white bands on legs. The adults rarely feed, while the larva feed on decaying organic matter in swampy areas.
Pygmy Phantom Crane fly, image courtesy Vipin Baliga
The Phantom Craneflies are very common in Mumbai, especially during Monsoon, as they hang along a string in shaded areas – often near marshy areas. I have not been able to get a photograph yet. I thank Vipin Baliga of India Nature Watch for providing me with the photograph taken in Karnataka.

NERIIDAE

This family is closely related to Micropezidae, which we talked about earlier. The flies in this family are called Cactus flies. They are very similar in appearance with Stilt-legged flies, but their forelegs are not reduced like that in Micropezidae. Their larvae feed on decaying vegetable matter, and adults are commonly seen near rotting fruits – this is in fact the best location to observe these flies.
Cactus fly (red arrow), image courtesy Hari Iyer
While I have not come across any Cactus flies in Mumbai, I am certain they will be common in SGNP, including its northern region (Nagla Block). Only more careful observations will confirm the presence of this family. I thank Hari Iyer of India Nature Watch for providing the photograph taken in Bhiwandi (Maharashtra).

TACHINIDAE

These flies are commonly called Tachinid flies, and are somewhat hard to distinguish from many Muscoid flies. The larvae are parasitic, developing inside caterpillars of butterflies, or grubs of beetles, or nymphs of bugs and grasshoppers. The adults can be easily distinguished by the presence of many bristles all over the body.
A typical Tachinid fly showing extensive bristle-like hair. This image
is for reference purpose only
I have provided this picture only as a reference, since it was photographed in Canada. This is a typical Tachinid fly. Although I have not come across any in Mumbai, given the fact that it is a large family common in the Indomalayan ecozone, their presence in Mumbai is obvious, but if not, it will be interest to look at why they are absent.

SEPSIDAE

This is another fly which is probably present in Mumbai. Commonly called Black Scavenger flies, they are more commonly seen feeding on dung. This is probably one reason why I have failed to observe them! These flies have a habit of waving their wings forward and backwards, much like the flies we will discuss below.

ULIDIIDAE

Most flies in this family have pictured wings, hence they are called Picture-winged flies, but many other flies (such as Bombyliidae and Tephritidae) are also mistakenly called Picture-winged flies. These flies are commonly seen sitting on branches, waving their wings, either as a territorial display or to attract females.
A Picture-winged fly
A common Picture-winged fly seen throughout Mumbai and
the surrounding areas
I have photographed two flies that may fall into this family, but further observations need to be done to confirm the presence of Ulidiidae in Mumbai.

BIBIONIDAE

The flies in this family are called March flies, or Love bugs (although they are not bugs). The adults are pollinators, thus very important to the ecosystems, while the larvae can be pests on some vegetables and crops. Although I have not  come across any records from Mumbai, I stumbled upon this picture taken by Satish Nikam at Mulshi (Pune). This is a good record not far from Mumbai; hence I have decided to include this family in the uncertain families section.

PLATYSTOMATIDAE

Another fly similar to the fly families discussed above bear resemblance to Muscidae and Tephritidae as well. The adults are common on decomposing vegetable and animals. It also requires further observations.

EPHYDRIDAE

Also called Shore flies or Brine flies, these are commonly seen along beaches and near ponds. Although telling some species apart from other families in Musciodea is difficult, one unique genus Ochthera, inhabits Mumbai.
Ochthera sp, commonly called Mantis fly, image courtesy Vipin Baliga
This genus is famous for its raptorial forelegs, which are used to capture and hold onto prey - just like a Preying Mantis, hence the common name - Mantis fly. I have only seen one specimen that managed to find its way into my home in 2007, and although I photographed it, I lost the original file. In their natural habitat, these flies can be seen in large swarms sitting on leaves, and take to flight is disturbed. As seen in the above photograph, these flies wave their raptorial forelegs, probably as a threat display or courtship dance. In the lone specimen I observed, the fly was waving its forelegs as well, although there were no other flies present. This photograph was taken in Karnataka by Vipin Baliga.

GNAT AND MIDGE FAMILIES

There are several families of these flies found all over the world. They are mostly small, mosquito-like flies that are either benign or parasitic. We have already seen benign non-biting midges, and the parasitic sandflies. Then there are Gall Midges and Gall Gnats (family Cecidomyiidae) that lay eggs in stems, leaves or flower buds, and develop inside – forming a gall like structure. The Gall Midges thus can be pests on some crops. There are Fungus gnats that fall in several families, Wood Gnats and Dixid midges amongst others. This group of families mostly goes unnoticed because of their small size.

There are other fly families such as Anthomyiidae that look very similar to Houseflies. These striking similarities as well as variations make Diptera a much complex and curious Order in Class Insecta. Only through keen interests of amateur naturalists and with the help of Dipterologists can we map this great diversity of such overlooked Order.

Conclusion

After looking at this great diversity, I am left with many questions in my mind, some sane, some metaphorical. I will keep questions like “will we discover a new species in Mumbai?” aside, and ask more general questions, such as “why aren’t flies studied as extensively as butterflies?” I already answered it in the introduction, but come to think about it, these flies do seem more interesting in their shapes, sizes, colours and behaviour than butterflies! We’re missing studying this great diversity shrouded in the magnificent wingspans of butterflies! (PS: No insect politics here). Jokes aside, it really is interesting to watch a Robberfly capture a Hoverfly since both are extremely aerodynamic, it is also interesting to observe Beeflies as they engage in territorial disputes.
A Blowfly caught by a Jumping Spider
A Bee fly caught by a Jumping Spider
A Robber fly wit ha Syrphid fly kill
This enormous Order is probably the only one which contains insects that spread diseases and insects that eat these disease-spreaders; insects that are pests and insects that eat these pests; and insects that decompose organic matter as well as pollinate, and provide a nutritious food source for other insects, birds, mammals, herptiles and fishes. Thus, flies form the base of a food pyramid, and without them, this world is definitely hard to imagine. Diptera is also an ideal candidate for research. We are already in debt of Drosophila flies for their contribution to our understanding of genetics. There is a vast scope in the field of malarial research, with their fly hosts seeking as much attention as the protists. We should also calculate the potential of flies for the purposes of pollination, as we have studied and realized how important bees are. Many flies are excellent biological pest controllers, that can be studied extensively and applied wherever needed, especially in eradication of certain pests. Their importance in degradation and decomposition must be evaluated so as to determine how ecologically important (like Fungi) fly larvae are to an ecosystem.

Now turning to some metaphoric questions, such as – why do only flies have to mimic other insects? I cannot recollect any insect that intentionally tries to mimic flies! Why do flowers with a butterfly sitting on it looks prettier than a fly sitting on a flower? We all know the answers, but today, lets raise a cup for the flies (the good and the bad), but make sure that none bite!

And a bonus picture!
A Pygmy Dartlet feeds on a Tiger Mosquito as a Crematogaster Ant watches in awe!
This study can be downloaded below:
Thank you for reading!

La Coccinelle

A 3D animation that looks into the daily life of bugs in a humorous, human perspective. It is a fine work of art by Thomas Szabo. Do check out his gallery!

Decoys, Shotguns and Conservation

A male Bluebill
I wandered far into the woods, into the lakes and over the snow, and waited patiently for an approaching deer, or a turkey, or, if I am on the lake, a duck, in anticipation of shooting one. But I found myself sitting on a bus on the way to the railway station. I was wondering what exactly I was going to do in the following 24 hours. It took me 6 hours to reach London, where it would have taken about 2. Nonetheless, I was too excited about the following day to be bothered by hours of waiting for buses and trains. I met a friend and we headed Turkey Point.

We started much before sunrise on the next day, as I piled layers of clothes to be able to withstand freezing cold and blistering winds blowing off Lake Erie. We joined two more friends, and then headed towards Long Point. Our trucks were full of decoys, anchors, guns and shells and two joyous canines. We loaded the stuff onto the boat and cruised towards the bay. It was foggy, damp and cold, and as our boat picked up speed I realized I was in for something more adventurous than I expected. It was my first hunting trip ever, as I joined professional hunters to observe and understand the ethics of real legal hunting.

When we hear the word hunting, the first thought that comes to our mind is killing, but in fact there is a big difference in the two terms. Hunting is what men did – and still do – in order to feed, as do wolves, tigers and lions. Killing is what men did – and still do – in order to claim territories, mates and others’ lives. It is as simple as that, but when one crosses the line of hunting mercilessly and illegally – as poachers do, that is when the art of hunting is tainted. In reality, poaching is far from hunting, it is nothing but slaughter for greed. And yet we always consider the words hunters and poachers as synonyms. It could probably be because of the media, but in order to understand the real meaning of hunting, one must understand that humans are a part of the ecosystem – we were (and still are) hunters, like wolves and tigers; as well as we were (and still are) hunted, like deer and antelopes . What separates us from the four legged hunters is our use of tools. From the first sphere carved out of a stone many centuries ago to the first gun used to hunt, we developed weapons from simple tools to obtain food. It is the weapons that have enabled us to become what we are today – efficient hunters. The other uses of weapons are already famous, so I’ll just focus on legal hunting and how it relates to wildlife conservation.
A Bluebill checking the decoys, and the hunter in the layout boat
Once we reached near the mouth of the bay, we set up the layout boat after carefully considering the position, the direction of the wind, as well as our proximity to other hunters. A layout boat is a small, flat boat that lays low on the surface of the water. It comes in variety of sizes, with room for two hunters, as well as for retriever dogs. The one we used housed single person. The boat was anchored in a strategic location near a cut on the nearby landmass, where the ducks might take cover or fly over. Direction of wind plays an important role in how the layout boat should be anchored, since you don’t want to be facing with the direction of the wind, but face the oncoming wind, so that you can see the approaching birds. Once the layout boat is in position, we need to attract the attention of the birds using decoys. These duck decoys are placed strategically around the boat. They are clamped onto a line with weights at both ends. We used Bufflehead, Canvasback, Redhead and Scaup decoys. There is a reason why the decoys were placed in a straight line. Some diver duck flocks prefer to land on the water in one straight line, and the decoys mimic this formation – inviting the ducks to join in. Some ducks, such as Buffleheads, randomly land on water – hence we placed decoys to mimic this behaviour. They are deployed in front of the layout boat so that the hunter is able to watch the ducks coming in. Using decoys is a very efficient technique to hunt ducks and geese. One might also wave the hat, or use a flag to mimic a landing duck – so as to attract attention of the ducks flying over. One may even mimic duck calls. Duck Calling is an art in itself, where a hunter has to train to hit the right notes. It is like singing, but in the language only ducks understand. There are even contests, and only one who is as good as the real duck/geese/turkey wins!

By now I realized that hunting is not like shooting clay pigeons in the air. There are many factors to be considered depending on what you’re out hunting. I’ll be more than happy if I ever have the opportunity to study how to hunt deer and geese. All these tricks have been tried and tested over time, discovered by other hunters and passed along to their kids and friends. This is how the legacy of hunting, just like any form of art, has come to be. Yet hunting is different than other forms of art, for it plays with life and death. As every art has its own history, hunting has a long one as well, although it is darker than any.

The primary source of food for man many centuries ago was wild meat and plants. Men hunt beasts the size of mammoths while women primarily foraged for vegetables. The first animal recorded to be extinct because of excessive hunting was the Dodo. Later, as agriculture and animal husbandry became common practice, hunting was transformed into a sport. The then-hunters were only sharp in shooting, since very few ever bothered to study the population dynamics of the game animals. In the following decades, this led to a great fall in populations of many animals, such as tigers and leopards, while many were hunted to extinction. This sport was more for the thrill-to-kill, than to be one with nature. Even today, the many animals on the brink of extinction are majorly because of indiscriminate hunting. This is one reason why people today nod in repulsion when a duck is harvested by a hunter, for it gave hunting a bad name.

While illegal hunting still takes place around the world, there are many rules and regulations set in order to curb this menace. These strict laws regulate when, where, what and how a person can hunt. The Ministry of Natural Resources mentions,
“Legal hunting does not endanger wildlife populations. In fact, it can play an important role in maintaining an abundant population within the carrying capacity of its habitat. Those species that are hunted are managed sustainably. The management is based on sound science and long-term monitoring.”    
Legal hunting also restricts a hunter to hunt only a few birds a day, depending on the species of the birds, for example, a hunter is only allowed to harvest two Buffleheads a day. Thanks to these laws, man can now be a part of the nature and be a real predator, and not just an aberrant hunter. The importance of hunting, as specified by MNR, is for wildlife management. The money from the fees paid to obtain the hunting license goes to monitoring and protection of wildlife. Today, hunting is an activity that is enjoyed equally by men and women. Hunting is not just a sexist sport anymore. It is a recreational sport – a sport to bond with people, to be a hunter and most of all to be one with nature.
Oscar retrieves a Bufflehead
Dawn cleared the fog, but clouds prevailed throughout the day. The wind, although not ideal, was blowing from west, which just might push the ducks inside the bay where the ambush was laid. One hunter went on the layout boat and we sailed a little farther from the trap. Very soon we heard a gunshot. “He’s down”, we heard on the radio. I barely saw the bird going down, but the dogs were the first to see it. Eager to fetch, Oscar jumped into the water after his master signaled him to. I saw this duck for the first time, a Bufflehead. And it was dead. I am not yet familiar to seeing the first-ever species I come across so lifeless, but there it was. I held my camera for a while, wondering if I should photograph a dead bird I saw for the first time. I do support sustainable hunting, but I was reluctant to photograph it. The dead duck was sniffed by the dogs, and kept beside the master. Lance and Oscar are Labrador retrievers. They are bred to fetch. They are also considered to be most lovable, social dogs. The training to become retrievers begins early in life, where the dog has to learn to obey his master, then to fetch objects and bring them to the master instead of carrying it away, then to fetch decoys, to sniff the birds, and then to fetch an actual bird. A Labrador retriever is a quick learner, hence favorite amongst most hunters.
A harvested male Bufflehead
We were four hunters on the boat, the three licensed to, and used to shoot with guns, and me with my camera. This was probably the commonest thing we had on that boat – we all were dedicated shooters. But as I came to understand, hunting is not about point-and-shoot which is what I did with my camera. As I discussed earlier, there are many factors crucial to hunting. While one has to consider the weather, most important factor is the time of the year. As lions know when and where the wildebeest will stop-over during migration, or as the wolves know when the elk migrate; a hunter has to learn when the birds arrive, and if they arrive, is the season right to hunt? This is because many birds stop-over at Long Point during their winter migration and spring migration, and some stay back to breed. The season of migration is generally considered hunting season, while it is not legal and ethical – to shoot the birds during breeding season. Therefore, to be a hunter is to be aware of everything that revolves around hunting – this also involves the lifecycle of the game animals.
Oscar - eager to fetch
About six hours later we shot three birds, two Buffleheads and a Ruddy duck. The number sounds too low for the time of the year. I started considering if we chose the wrong place, or was the weather too bad? Or sheer bad luck? I got a simple explanation, “that’s why it’s hunting and not killing.” What draws the line between hunting and killing are the intentions of the gunman. The hunters could have easily shot every passing bird, and bring down a hundred gulls and mergansers. This is not the intention of a real hunter.
Long Point
Long Point is a rich habitat for staging migrants; hence it is not surprising to see hunters flocking in as well. A major landmass of Long Point is restricted for the sole purpose of hunting. It may sound cruel, but it is because of this measure that it has become a haven for the birds. Long Point is a sand-spit with large shallow wetlands – an ideal habitat for waterfowls to feed and breed in. It is great example of sustainable-conservation. To understand why sustainability and conservation are combined one must consider that the waterfowls would, as any animal from bacteria to humans, over-exploit the resources in the absence of predators. This could lead to population explosion, which is not healthy for any given habitat. As predators, humans can sustain a healthy population of waterfowls; just as tigers maintain the populations of the deer or as Ladybird beetles that maintain the populations of aphids.

This brings me to question a common notion used by many biologists – “natural predators”. If humans are not natural predators, what are we? Definitely not supernatural. Whether it is the world of insect predators or mammal predators, we all are natural at predating. I was once told of an interesting story, where the pest populations of White-tailed Deer were controlled by natural predators – humans. The deer were introduced to Long Point many years ago. Since there were no natural predators such as wolves to prey on them, they grew beyond Long Point’s carrying capacity, which lead to destruction of many virgin Carolinian forests. What we forgot is that we are a part of nature as well. Reintroduction of wolves to curb deer population is another solution that is debatable. Today, licensed hunters maintain the populations of deer at Long Point, making sure that there are not too many, nor too less. Similarly for waterfowls, man is the primary predator of this wetland, as the tiger is of Ranthambore.

Since I hail from the land of the tiger, I wondered why isn’t hunting a sport in India as it is in North America, Europe and Africa. The basic reason that I think of is land availability. India is a big country, but even bigger is the biodiversity of this country. I think the competition within predator-prey of India’s wildlife is far fierce and competitive than North America (primarily Canada). India also has many endangered animals, which rely on other animals of least concern for food – this makes conservation of the least-concern animals vital for the survival of the endangered ones. Hence hunting is strictly illegal in India, although many tribes are exempted from this law since hunting is their primary source of meat. It is in this class of tribes that unfortunately gives rise to poachers, because poaching is an easy source of income – and they are very skilled to hunt in the Indian forests.
LPW logo on the cap
While I did not leave my body on the boat and wander into Indian wilderness, I enjoyed every bit of what I learnt within a few hours. Long Point Waterfowl, that gave me the opportunity (and a degree!) to work and learn about Canadian wilderness, continues to educate me. It is one of the major bodies working for conservation of Long Point – a fascinating land where man is still a natural, real and legal predator.
The string that held decoys became tangled in the propeller
At the end of the day, we harvested four birds – with the addition of a female Bluebill. I’m glad we did not get stunk (a hunter says he got stunk when he fails to harvest a game animal). We rescued the lost decoys; untangled strings caught up in the propeller, and hauled the boat to the dock. “Look at that!” pointed a friend to the sky – and we saw what every hunter despise – a flock of Redheads and Canvasbacks in thousands heading toward the bay. We all sighed. The lesson to be learnt was clear. Even if it’s a perfect day to hunt, more than half of the chance that you will hunt is upon your luck.
Long Point Bay
I was back on the train the same day. I was exhausted, yet excited for the day turned out to be very educational. Wildlife conservation is not possible without immersing ourselves into this web of life. A hunter knows how to be a part of this web, but many people who have distanced themselves from nature fail to understand this concept. I see a hunter as a conservationist and a naturalist – as long as he is bound by the laws of sustainable hunting.